Should You Put Money in a CD or a Savings Account

February 11, 2019

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

As good stewards of your money, there are moments in life when you must park your money safely for a short period.  Because you need to be able to access it in the future for purchases or perhaps for other reasons, investing in the market is out of the question.    

Putting your money under your mattress creates additional risk, so you are keen to the idea of storing it in a savings account or CD.  But which do you pick?  In this blog, we will dive into the components to make you a wiser investor and a better steward of your money. 

 

A Certificate of Deposit (CD) is a promissory note, short-term investment, allowing consumers to earn a fixed rate of interest over a designated period.  For instance, Marcus by Goldman Sachs is offering a one year CD at 2.75% APY, Annual Percentage Yield-- the real interest of earnings per year.  

 

This type of CD is also considered a High-Yield CD because it is one of the top rates currently being offered across the financial industry.  Instantly, the CD may be appealing to you, and perhaps it is ideal, but we will explore what to be on the lookout for when buying CDs, as well as, determining if a savings account is the right option for you.

You will discover:

  • Why Certificates of Deposit

  • Comparison of a Savings Account to a CD

  • FDIC Insured

  • Types of Risks

  • Why Compounded Interest Matters

Most banks and credit unions offer such instruments as long as a customer can meet their initial deposit.  For example, if the minimum deposit for a CD is $500, then the consumer must have $500 to put into that account.  Typically, CDs of $100,000 or more are called Jumbo CDs.  Amounts smaller than $100,000 are just referred to as CDs.

 

Once you purchased a CD, it is locked into an account for a designated period you choose.  The longer the period, the higher the rate should be.  According to Bankrate.com, a one-year CD national average is earning 0.88% compared to a five-year CD earning 1.44%.  

 

Savings Accounts or CD?

 

When it comes to deciding which account to put your money, the answer lies in the purpose of your investment or why you are saving.  If someone is looking to store cash in a haven for a short period earning little to no interest and do not want to be penalized for making withdrawals from their account, then a savings account may be an option.  Please note that many savings accounts have an annual withdrawal limit.  

 

For instance, according to USAA's Service Fee Schedule, the first withdrawal from a savings account is free but the second withdrawal is subject to a $5 fee.  The third withdrawal may be converted to a checking account while closing the savings account as well as a $5 fee.

 

A certificate of deposit may be an option if you need to store funds for a short period.  As of the date of this blog, a one-year CD National Average rate is 0.88% compared to the national average of a savings account, 0.10%.  
Below is a chart of how the two perform against each other based on historical and current rates.  CDs can range from one-month to five years but also based on the financial institution.

 

FDIC Insured?
 

 Like savings accounts, CDs are FDIC insured up to $250,000 per account.  If you have three CDs at $250,000 each deposited into one account, you are insured up to $250,000 leaving the remaining $500,000 at risk.  

 

However, as the FDIC provides coverage "per account," you can deposit each CD into three separate accounts, and the FDIC will insure each $250,000 account helping to secure your $750,000 investment.  Just note that any interest over this limit is at risk. 

 

It also irks me to see banks posting CDs as risk-free investments.  From one investor to another, there is no such thing as risk-free investments, not even U.S. bonds.  Everything has risk.  The types of risks that CDs face are inflation risk and liquidity risk.  

 

Risks: Inflation & Liquidity

 

Inflation

 

When it comes to investing, your investment always has a risk, and it comes in many forms. The first type of risk you need to understand is Inflation Risk.  Such a threat is the loss of purchasing power over time.  Each month, the Bureau of Labor Statistics measures "the average change over time in the prices paid by urban consumers for a market basket of consumer goods and services."  Professors have taught in business schools that a healthy rate of annual inflation should be between 2-3% annum.  If inflation gets too high, consumers struggle to pay for goods.

 

In 1917, the United States saw its highest inflation rate of 19.66%!  If we saw inflation spike like this, your $2.24 gallon per gas now would cost $2.68.  May not sound too bad until you consider all of your expenses spiking around 20%.  Your credit cards would increase by this amount, if not more.  Your investments could no longer keep pace with inflation, thereby, losing money. 

 

Inflation causes concerns.  Look back at the thriving country, Argentina.  It was a coveted place to visit, and the economy was very similar to the U.S. until 1975 through 1990 when inflation spiked over 300%.   Inflation caused prices to double every few months.  "Prices rose at an explosive annual rate of more than 1,000% in 1989, before inflation was finally brought under control."  This would make your CDs, savings account, and investments practically worthless. 

 

The end goal for all investors is to beat inflation because it eats away at your purchasing power.  In the below chart, I have depicted the growth of a CD and a savings account based on current national averages as of the blog's date to help illustrate how inflation will usually beat these two investments. 

 

The chart above provides a clear visual that by investing in a CD, you lose purchasing power by $24.20 over the five years depicted and this is during regular inflationary periods. 


Every year countries strive to maintain growth in inflation rates.  This leads to political issues such as raising minimum wages, but in reality, prices indeed remain relatively stagnant. 

 

For example, in 1979, a gallon of gas cost approximately $0.63 per gallon. Sound cheap?  Well, adding the inflation rate to this amount to keep prices comparative, an apples-to-apples comparison, the price is around $2.24 a gallon.  This price isn't much different from today's prices.  Read how inflation impacted the U.S. during the 1970's.

 

Now had this $0.63 been invested, at the annual inflation rate, you would have felt zero impact.  Had you stuffed the $0.63 in your mattress or buried it outside in your backyard, you would be short today and can only afford about a 1/4 a gallon of gas. You are not traveling very far.  That is why any investment and money saved, MUST at a minimum keep pace with inflation. 

 

Liquidity

 

One of the most critical components to saving money is determining its liquidity.  Liquidity refers to the ability to transition an investment, in this case, a CD or savings account, into cash. 


When you have money in a checking account, you have quick access to cash.  A savings account is also liquid, but depending on the bank's fee schedule, you may be able to withdrawal the funds for free the initial time or may be charged a fee.  Let it alone; you have access to cash. 


A CD is not as liquid as a savings account, but it is still a liquid investment.  You will be charged a fee for early withdrawal as well as may be taxed in the future on any interest earned on it. 


Unlike owning a savings bond, having a CD or money in a savings account are both very liquid instruments. 

 

 

To learn about the different types of CDs, visit Bankrate.com.

 

Compound Interest

 

When purchasing a CD, it is highly encouraged to review the compounded interest schedule.  It does make a difference when a CD is compounded daily compared to annually.  

 

When money is compounded daily, it is recalculated helping you to earn interest on interest.  Daily compounding makes your money grow faster when compared to the annual compound.  


An annual compound is precisely what it is.  Your money is calculated once per year meaning your interest won't earn interest until the following year. 

 

Conclusion

 

The comparison between a savings account and a CD have similarities and differences.  By understanding what is your goal and how soon you need to access your money, will determine whether a CD or savings account is the appropriate investment.

 
Both are short-term tools but if you think you need to access the money prior to the CD's maturity date, then a savings account is more appropriate.  If you do not need the funds but want to keep it semi-liquid and earn more interest than a traditional savings account, then a CD may be the preferable choice for you.

Nick Carroll is a published author of 6 Steps to Achieve Financial Freedom and has worked as a Commercial Credit Analyst, Investment Marketing Associate, and worked at the Pentagon-Air Force Budget Office.  He is a graduate of Creighton University with a Masters in Investment Management and Financial Analysis and holds a Bachelor's in Banking & Finance.

 

 

 

​​
 

 

Please reload

follow us

  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Pinterest Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey YouTube Icon

Previous Articles

Practical Ways to Save Money | Saving Tips

November 17, 2019

2019 Veterans Day Deals, Meals, and More

November 11, 2019

Rental Car Insurance or Your Private Auto Insurance?

November 4, 2019

1/1
Please reload

MEDIA

INSIGHTS

SUPPORT

PRODUCTS

Online Courses

© Dollar Otter and www.dollarotter.com, 2019.  Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site's author and/or owner is strictly prohibited.  Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Dollar Otter and www.dollarotter.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.